Home
Membership & Communities
Renew
Join ASCE
Member Benefits
Upgrade Your Membership
Civil Engineering Salaries
Manage Your Account
Volunteer Opportunities
ASCE Collaborate
ASCE Merchandise
Regions, Sections, & Branches
International
Institutes
Technical Groups
Academies
Younger Members
Student Chapters
Industry Leaders Council
Education & Careers
Training & Courses
Getting Licensed & Certified
Live Exam Reviews
Specialty Certifications
Civil Engineering Body of Knowledge
Volunteer Opportunities
Mentoring
Jobs
Ethics
Diversity and Inclusion
Civil Engineering Salaries
Pre-College Outreach
Student Member Resources
University Curriculum Development
Conferences & Events
Conferences
Continuing Education
Award Deadlines
Call for Papers
Conference Proceedings
Sponsoring & Exhibiting
Volunteer Opportunities
Issues & Advocacy
Infrastructure
Sustainability
Engineer Tomorrow
ASCE Grand Challenge
Disaster Response
Infrastructure Report Card
Advocacy
Tools & Training
Volunteer Opportunities
Publications
Books & Standards
ASCE 7
Contract Documents
ASCE Library
Civil Engineering Database (CEDB)
Journals
Conference Proceedings
Civil Engineering Source
Bridges Calendar
Civil Engineering Magazine
Society News
Civil Engineering Salaries
GEOSTRATA Magazine
Infrastructure Report Card
Official Register
Volunteer Opportunities
Technical Areas
Architectural Engineering
Coasts, Oceans, Ports, and Rivers
Construction
Engineering Mechanics
Environmental & Water Resources
Geotechnical Engineering
Structural Engineering
Transportation & Development
Utility Engineering and Surveying
Volunteer Opportunities
Aerospace
Changing Climate
Codes & Standards
Cold Regions Engineering
Computing
Energy
Forensic Engineering
Infrastructure Resilience
Join
Renew
Donate
Member Login
Help
Menu
Membership & Communities
Membership
Renew
Join ASCE
Member Benefits
Upgrade Your Membership
Civil Engineering Salaries
Manage Your Account
Volunteer Opportunities
ASCE Collaborate
ASCE Merchandise
ASCE Communities
Regions, Sections, & Branches
International
Institutes
Technical Groups
Academies
Younger Members
Student Chapters
Industry Leaders Council
Education & Careers
Continuing Education
Training & Courses
Licensure & Certification
Getting Licensed & Certified
Live Exam Reviews
Specialty Certifications
Civil Engineering Body of Knowledge
Get Involved
Volunteer Opportunities
Career & Workforce Development
Mentoring
Jobs
Ethics
Diversity and Inclusion
Civil Engineering Salaries
Support for Students & Teachers
Pre-College Outreach
Student Member Resources
University Curriculum Development
Conferences & Events
Events Calendar
Conferences
Continuing Education
Award Deadlines
Conferences
Call for Papers
Conference Proceedings
Sponsoring & Exhibiting
Volunteer Opportunities
Issues & Advocacy
Infrastructure
Sustainability
Engineer Tomorrow
ASCE Grand Challenge
Disaster Response
Infrastructure Report Card
Advocacy
Tools & Training
Volunteer Opportunities
Publications
Books & Standards
ASCE 7
Contract Documents
ASCE Library
Civil Engineering Database (CEDB)
Journals
Conference Proceedings
Civil Engineering Source
Bridges Calendar
Civil Engineering Magazine
Society News
Civil Engineering Salaries
GEOSTRATA Magazine
Infrastructure Report Card
Official Register
Volunteer Opportunities
Technical Areas
Institutes
Architectural Engineering
Coasts, Oceans, Ports, and Rivers
Construction
Engineering Mechanics
Environmental & Water Resources
Geotechnical Engineering
Structural Engineering
Transportation & Development
Utility Engineering and Surveying
Get Involved
Volunteer Opportunities
Technical Groups
Aerospace
Changing Climate
Codes & Standards
Cold Regions Engineering
Computing
Energy
Forensic Engineering
Infrastructure Resilience
Membership & Communities
Membership
Renew
Join ASCE
Member Benefits
Upgrade Your Membership
Civil Engineering Salaries
Manage Your Account
Volunteer Opportunities
ASCE Collaborate
ASCE Merchandise
ASCE Communities
Regions, Sections, & Branches
International
Institutes
Technical Groups
Academies
Younger Members
Student Chapters
Industry Leaders Council
Education & Careers
Continuing Education
Training & Courses
Licensure & Certification
Getting Licensed & Certified
Live Exam Reviews
Specialty Certifications
Civil Engineering Body of Knowledge
Get Involved
Volunteer Opportunities
Career & Workforce Development
Mentoring
Jobs
Ethics
Diversity and Inclusion
Civil Engineering Salaries
Support for Students & Teachers
Pre-College Outreach
Student Member Resources
University Curriculum Development
Conferences & Events
Events Calendar
Conferences
Continuing Education
Award Deadlines
Conferences
Call for Papers
Conference Proceedings
Sponsoring & Exhibiting
Volunteer Opportunities
Issues & Advocacy
Infrastructure
Sustainability
Engineer Tomorrow
ASCE Grand Challenge
Disaster Response
Infrastructure Report Card
Advocacy
Tools & Training
Volunteer Opportunities
Publications
Books & Standards
ASCE 7
Contract Documents
ASCE Library
Civil Engineering Database (CEDB)
Journals
Conference Proceedings
Civil Engineering Source
Bridges Calendar
Civil Engineering Magazine
Society News
Civil Engineering Salaries
GEOSTRATA Magazine
Infrastructure Report Card
Official Register
Volunteer Opportunities
Technical Areas
Institutes
Architectural Engineering
Coasts, Oceans, Ports, and Rivers
Construction
Engineering Mechanics
Environmental & Water Resources
Geotechnical Engineering
Structural Engineering
Transportation & Development
Utility Engineering and Surveying
Get Involved
Volunteer Opportunities
Technical Groups
Aerospace
Changing Climate
Codes & Standards
Cold Regions Engineering
Computing
Energy
Forensic Engineering
Infrastructure Resilience
Issues & Advocacy
Advocacy
Key Programs
Infrastructure
2017 Report Card
Failure to Act Reports
Infrastructure Policy Reports
Life Cycle Cost Analysis Report
State and Regional Report Cards
Engineer Tomorrow
Sustainability
Sustainability at ASCE
Sustainability Resources
Sustainability Project Profiles
Envision
Sustainable Infrastructure Certificate Program
Sustainability Roadmap
ASCE Grand Challenge
Advocacy
Public Policy Statements
Priority Issues
Letters, Comments and Statements
Key Contact Program
Advocate of the Year Award
Back Home Visits
Legislative Fly-in
Contact Your Legislator
Tools & Training
PR and GR Universities
Construction Procurement
Qualifications Based Selection for Engineering Services
Summary
Since 1972, the federal government has required every agency to award contracts for architectural and engineering services using the qualifications based-selection (QBS) process created under the Brooks Architect-Engineers Act of 1972. The QBS process assures the government of obtaining the most-qualified professional services at the most reasonable cost to the agency.
QBS requires the agency client to negotiate a contract at a price that it decides “is fair and reasonable to the federal government.” Low bids requiring substantial change orders or resulting in high construction or high life-cycle operating or maintenance costs are not cost-effective.
The QBS procedure assures the selection of the best qualified firm. The agency client identifies three qualified firms and begins negotiations with the firm most likely to meet the government’s needs. If a contract cannot be procured at a fair and reasonable price to the agency, the government stops negotiations with the first firm and begins negotiations with the second firm and so on. The process ends when all parties agree on a fair and reasonable price for the services required. Under QBS, firms compete based on their professional qualifications and quality of services, which allows large and small firms alike to compete on an equal footing.
ASCE is a founding and active member of the
Council on Federal Procurement of Architectural and Engineering Services
(COFPAES) whose goal it is to promote sound architectural and engineering procurement practices through the use of competitive negotiations under QBS procedures of the Brooks Architect-Engineers Act of 1972.
Activity in the 116th Congress
ASCE will attempt, where appropriate, to add QBS language to existing non-covered federal programs.
Recent Success
In October 2018, favorable QBS language was included in the reauthorization of the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) (
P.L.115-254
) which expands the QBS process to cover any airport project that uses federal Airport Improvement Program (AIP) funds at any stage (Section 131). Additionally, existing QBS requirements and state licensing laws under the Geospatial Data title of the FAA reauthorization were not weakened and remain constant (Section 759B).
As of December 2016, QBS is required for projects financed with loans from the EPA’s Clean Water State Revolving Fund (CWSRF). The Water Infrastructure Improvements for the Nation (WIIN) Act, passed in 2016, extended the Brooks Act to the CWSRF program.
ASCE Position
Congress should extend the scope of the QBS process to federal grant programs that finance essential public works infrastructure, including those administered by the Federal Aviation Administration, governed by Passenger Facility Charges (PFCs).
ASCE supports the use of the two-phase competitive source-selection process required by the Federal Acquisition Reform Act of 1996 for design-build contracts awarded by government agencies. The design-build team must be selected using the modified QBS criteria specified by the Act. The contract between the design-build team and the owner must establish the means for direct communication between the owner and the designer as well as other team members. On complex projects, the owner should provide predetermined reimbursement for the firms selected to make complete design-build proposals.
Further Information
ASCE Policy Statement 304 - Qualifications-Based Selection of Professional Engineers
ASCE Policy Statement 400 - Design-Build Procurement
Council on Federal Procurement of Architectural and Engineering Services (COFPAES)
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement