Photo of Brooklyn Bridge
Are we investing in infrastructure to support future needs, or are we continuously responding to problems that could have been avoided?
What if we measured the success of infrastructure not only by the problems it solves, but also by the problems it prevents?

I recently attended the World Infrastructure Forum in Madrid with MIT, where leaders in engineering, finance, urban planning, and public policy came together and discussed the future of global infrastructure. 

Although many topics were discussed, one idea that resonated with me is that we must stop treating infrastructure as a collection of individual projects and start recognizing it as a system of interconnected investments. 

This raised an important question: Are we investing in infrastructure to support future needs, or are we continuously responding to problems that could have been avoided? 

This question prompted me to think about how much of our society’s infrastructure is reactive instead of proactive. We expand highways in response to traffic congestion, improve drainage systems following severe flooding, and increase utility capacity when existing networks can no longer support their growing populations. These investments are necessary, but they also highlight a fundamental challenge in how we approach infrastructure planning. 

To me, reactive infrastructure is a series of investments made in response to existing problems, deficiencies, or unforeseen consequences rather than through long-term planning that anticipates future demands. Not all reactive infrastructure is avoidable. Natural disasters and evolving technological demands are just two of many inevitable instances that will require adaptation.

But there is a difference between unpredictable circumstances and problems that could have been prevented with comprehensive planning. 

In my opinion, proactive infrastructure requires identifying immediate needs and anticipating how those needs will evolve. Infrastructure should be designed around future population growth, climate change, anticipated advancements in technology, and the relationships between infrastructure systems. 

These predictions do not need to be made with certainty but with the acknowledgement of uncertainty. Systems need to be capable of accommodating changing needs, and we need to quantify the capacity of these systems to change. 

I think one way to begin addressing this challenge is for disciplines that have traditionally approached infrastructure development independently to start collaborating. Engineers, urban planners, economists, policymakers, and financial institutions coming together in design – in the same way they did at the infrastructure forum – to have open lines of communication. That is important. 

Proactive planning requires investments in problems that haven’t happened yet. Justifying funding for a visibly deteriorating bridge or a flooded neighborhood after a hurricane is easy; investing in improving something that you cannot physically see is failing (yet) under a capacity to perform that it hasn’t seen (yet) is harder.

So, what is successful infrastructure?  

Resilience should be measured by how infrastructure responds to failure and how well it prevents failure from occurring at all. 

Proactive infrastructure requires anticipating society’s future demands and designing flexible infrastructure systems that have the capacity for growth and the anticipation of changing needs. Society should not be dependent on reactive infrastructure.